How do roofers figure out their real cost per closed job?

By Vince Ceniceros · Published

Add up everything you spent on one lead source for a set period, then divide by the number of signed jobs that came from that source. That number is your cost per closed job. Cost per lead tells you what a phone call cost you. Cost per closed job tells you what a roof cost you to win.

Why can a cheap lead cost you more than an expensive one?

Because you don’t get paid for leads. You get paid for signed jobs. A lead source that looks cheap per lead can be the most expensive one you run if almost none of those homeowners sign.

Here’s a real number we can publish: one roofer got 33 leads at $41.38 in 30 days. That’s a cost per lead. To turn it into a cost per closed job you need one more number: how many of those 33 homeowners signed. Without that second number, you’re only seeing half the math.

What should you count as the cost of a lead source?

Count every dollar that only exists because of that source. Keep the rule the same for every source so you can compare them fairly.

  • Ad spend or lead fees. What you paid Google, Facebook, a lead company or a directory for that period.
  • Monthly fees tied to that source. Platform, software or agency fees you’d stop paying if you dropped it.
  • Your team’s time, if you want the full picture. Hours spent chasing that source’s leads. Leave it out if you can’t measure it the same way for every source.

How do you know which jobs came from which source?

Write the source down on every lead the moment it comes in, then mark it when the homeowner signs. A spreadsheet or your CRM works. What matters is that every signed job traces back to one source.

Ad platforms can help close the loop:

  • Google Ads. Google’s offline conversion imports let you measure what happens offline, such as a sale over the phone, after someone clicks your ad or calls your business. That sends your closed jobs back to Google instead of stopping at the form fill. Our guide on whether Google Ads still work for roofers covers the rest of the setup.
  • Google Local Services Ads. In the U.S. and Canada, Google lets advertisers track bookings in the Local Services dashboard. Our guide to Google Local Services Ads for roofers covers how those ads work.

How long should you wait before you run the numbers?

Long enough for the leads to close. Roofing jobs often don’t sign the same week the lead comes in. Count the spend and the leads for one month, then come back after your normal sales cycle and count how many of those leads signed.

If you run the math too early, every source looks worse than it is. If you run it on a tiny sample, one lucky job can make a bad source look great. Give each source enough leads before you judge it.

What do you do once you know each source’s number?

Put the sources side by side and look at cost per closed job, not cost per lead. Then:

  1. Keep feeding the source that wins roofs for the least. Even if its leads cost more.
  2. Fix before you cut. Slow callbacks lose jobs no matter where the lead came from. See how fast to call a lead back and how to follow up.
  3. Work backward to a lead target. Once you know your close rate, how many leads you need each month is simple math.

I’ll be honest: this math won’t make any lead source better. It shows you which ones are already working, so you stop paying for the ones that aren’t. If you buy from lead companies, our guide on how to pick a roofing lead company shows what to ask before you sign up.

Sources

Where to go next